Reconfiguring our dementia care system — Part 1
For thirteen years I was the full-time caregiver for my wife Lena after her diagnosis with early-onset Alzheimer’s. (Later Lena’s symptoms bore all the characteristics of frontotemporal dementia, although that was never formally diagnosed.) Thanks to the support of my adult children and the local hospice, I was able to care for Lena at home — where she and I both wanted her to be — right up until the end in 2025.
During those years I often heard caregivers like myself referred to as ‘service users’. And I began to think about the services that the care system provided to people with dementia who lived in their own homes. Primarily assistance with personal care for an hour or two a day — washing, dressing, feeding, taking medication, and so forth. Was that really all we needed? What about caregiver training? What about better access to information? What about loneliness, as dementia separated us from friends and neighbours? And what about boredom — figuring out what to do for all the other hours in those long days?
This is an article I wrote in 2018, some five years after Lena’s diagnosis. It was the first in a series exploring what those with dementia and their carers really wanted, and then how we could provide it.
My views haven’t changed. And they underpin The Care Combine, the plan I’m now shaping to transform dementia care for those diagnosed, their carers, their families … and, not least, the state.
The September 2018 article
The original text is unchanged. Notes I’ve added in 2026 are in square brackets.
+ + +
What do we mean by good dementia care?
The answer? It depends on your point of view.
The professionals’ view
I’m grateful to John Cresswell, who first raised the question on LinkedIn recently, sparking an interesting debate. John got the conversation started with a few ideas of his own:
“Beautiful well designed dementia layouts and wayfinding, choice driven support every minute of the day, a robustness to protect our vulnerable, thinking outside the box, better approaches to crisis, healthy living, faster information, investing in our children, and dying well. Dementia friendly cities, towns and villages, public areas like railway stations, airports, supermarkets. Reliability, consistency, great communication with other professionals.”
That’s the way the care professional tends to see it. All well-meaning objectives, worthy of applause.
The fear of being warehoused
But for most people living with dementia, I suspect — at least those who are still self-aware — there’s a concern that dwarfs anything the professionals are discussing. No, not a concern: a fear. In a recent blog-post [2026: no longer online] I quote Minna Packer, diagnosed with Early-Onset Alzheimer’s around 18 months ago [i.e. in 2017]. She writes:
“Don’t warehouse us with untrained workers who are overwhelmed with caring for dozens of dementia patients. Find another way.”
Long-term residential care. Minna calls it warehousing. I call it parking. Whichever word we use, it’s the action of setting something aside because it’s just not useful, not required right now. It’s inconvenient to have it around, so we leave it somewhere else. Somewhere safe. Out of sight preferably.
Maybe you’re protesting: “But that’s not how it is. I work in a fabulous care-home where all the staff love the residents and will do anything for them …” To which I reply: “That’s how you see it. And I’m sure that what you’re telling me is true. But how will you feel when your family, those closest to you, decide that you’re too much of a burden to them? Will you just give them a jaunty smile as you wave them goodbye?”
For the person with dementia, good care means freedom from the fear of being institutionalised, of being in the hands of strangers, of being unnecessary, a bit of a nuisance really.
What carers want
But what about family dementia carers? What would improve their lives? What would they regard as good care? Well, here I can speak for myself, having done the job for the last five years. [Note added 2026: I went on caring for Lena at home for another seven years, until her death in 2025.] What I can tell you unequivocally is that, while I appreciate the suggestions on the care professionals’ list, none of them would make a jot of difference to my life. So what would?
Having the same kind of relationship that I had with Lena for the first 30 years of our married life. That’s what I’d like.
No, I’m not talking about the marital relationship. Living with Lena now is like living with a small child rather than a wife. It’s not what I’d have wished, and I found it difficult at first to make the adjustment. But there’s still pleasure in the relationship … remember when the kids were tiny and entirely dependent on you, not able to communicate with words yet? How much fun you still had together? That’s how it feels — and I can live with that. We certainly haven’t lost everything.
But by “the same kind of relationship”, I mean the same daily living arrangements. In the old days, we’d get up in the morning, have breakfast, and then both go about our business for the whole working day. Separately. We were a pair, united, but we also both had the opportunity to function and grow as individuals. We each did our own thing. So did the kids. And then we all came back together again in the evening as a family. That was healthy.
Trapped together
What’s unhealthy is our changed situation today, brought upon us by Lena’s total dependence on me and the absence of any care support system that allows us to escape one another’s clutches. Yes, there are befriending agencies that could offer a few hours of respite a week — at a price. And there are plenty of dementia activity groups around, giving a couple of hours of enjoyment away from the house. But a couple of hours here and there doesn’t cut it. In a different way from Lena, dementia has taken over my life too. I can’t work. There’s no time for the things I enjoy. I’ve stopped developing.
I said that taking care of small children was fun. But what if they stayed small and helpless for year after year, and you were alone in the house with them every single day — without a partner to help you, without a prospect that some day soon they’d be going off to school? Not so much fun then, eh? Is it any wonder that almost 50% of dementia carers have a long-term health condition themselves?
[Note added 2026: if anything, I understated the figure. A 2024 study of nearly 1,000 people caring for a husband, wife or partner with dementia in Great Britain found that 73% had at least one long-term health condition, rising to 82% two years later.]
My contention is that the stress of full-time dementia care is the reason why so many of us choose to do exactly what our partners with dementia fear the most. We warehouse them — for the sake of our own sanity … and (we persuade ourselves) for their own wellbeing. Because a run-down, worn-out, frayed-at-the-edges carer is no good to them at all. They’d be better off in a place where they’ll get proper professional care, we assure our guilty conscience. They need a little more love.
Can the children take over?
And then of course there are those with dementia who no longer have a living partner. They depend on their children for care, maybe go to live with them. Which would be fine if their children didn’t have kids of their own, and jobs, and responsibilities, financial and otherwise. Of course they love their parent and they only want the best for them. So of course they can stay. What does it matter if there’s an extra mouth to feed and an extra person to help get ready? Except …
— What’s grandpa going to do in the house all day while we’re away? It’s not safe for him to be alone all that time, unsupervised. I suppose I could stop working. But …
The way our care system is configured, there really is nobody else to support grandpa all day. So we come to the same agonising but necessary solution. It’s warehousing.
Next time: The blindingly obvious solution the experts missed.

